Is Mortgage Haram in Islam?
September 11, 2023
In the vast world of modern finance, the concept of mortgages is ubiquitous. For many, it’s a means to achieve the dream of homeownership. However, from an Islamic point of view, people often ask, “Is mortgage haram?” This isn’t just a religious question; it also looks at how society is affected, highlighting the differences between the rich and the poor.
The Quranic Stance on Riba
To understand why many scholars claim mortgages are prohibited in Islam, one must first grasp the concept of “riba”.
What is Riba?
Riba, in its most basic understanding, refers to the extra amount that a borrower pays to the lender above the principal sum. It’s seen as unjust enrichment and exploitation. The Quran states, “O you who have believed, do not consume one another’s wealth unjustly but only [in lawful] business by mutual consent. And do not kill the soul which Allah has forbidden, except by right. Indeed, that is ever an enormity.” (4:29)
Riba, often translated as “interest” or “usury”, represents any guaranteed interest on loaned money. In conventional mortgages, banks lend money for purchasing homes, with borrowers repaying a sum greater than the loaned amount due to accumulated interest. This system is where many deduce the verdict: “are mortgages haram?” By the very definition of riba, conventional mortgages fall into this category.
Mortgages and Riba
In a conventional mortgage, a person borrows money from a bank to buy a home. Over time, the borrower repays the bank the amount borrowed plus interest. This interest presents a challenge for many Muslims because they see it as a form of riba.
The Quran says, “Those who consume interest cannot stand [on the Day of Resurrection] except as one stands who is being beaten by Satan into insanity…” (2:275). This stern warning underscores the gravity of dealing with riba.
Hadiths Reiterating the Warning Against Riba
The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) highlighted the severity of riba in multiple hadiths. One such narration mentions, “Avoid the seven grave sins,” and among those he listed was “consuming riba” (Sahih Bukhari). In another, he said, “A dirham of riba which a man receives knowingly is worse than committing adultery thirty-six times” (Mishkat al-Masabih). Given the weight of these warnings, many scholars and followers stand firmly by the belief that mortgage is haram.
How Mortgages Exacerbate Socio-economic Disparities
Beyond religious edicts, the question of “is mortgage haram mufti menk?” sheds light on broader socio-economic concerns. Renowned scholars like Mufti Menk emphasize the societal pitfalls of interest-based systems. Mortgages, as instruments of riba, perpetuate wealth disparity. Here’s how:
- Exploitative Nature of Interest: As interest accrues, borrowers often pay much more than a property’s worth. This system benefits the wealthy – those with the capital to lend – while impoverishing those without the means to buy without loans.
- Debt Cycles: The less privileged often find themselves in unending cycles of debt due to high interest, trapping them in financial instability.
- Economic Inequalities: On a broader scale, interest-driven economies can exacerbate wealth gaps, concentrating resources in the hands of a few, while many struggle with escalating debts.
Islamic Alternatives to Conventional Mortgages
Understanding that homeownership is a legitimate aspiration, Islamic finance offers alternatives that align with Sharia principles. To address this concern, some financial institutions offer “Islamic mortgages” or home-buying plans that comply with sharia law. These alternatives avoid conventional interest-based transactions by using contracts based on partnerships or lease-to-own models. Common models include:
- Musharakah (Partnership) Agreement: Both the buyer and the bank co-own the property. Over time, the buyer purchases the bank’s share, and ownership gradually shifts to the buyer.
- Ijara (Leasing): The bank buys the property and then leases it to the client for a fixed period. At the end of the term, the client receives ownership.
These systems prioritize equitable and just transactions, ensuring neither party exploits the other.
If you’re passionate about deepening your knowledge on such topics and exploring the Quranic foundations behind them, sign up for our program at IQRA Network. For a diverse range of courses on the Quran and Arabic, explore our offerings here.
The query, “is mortgage haram?” isn’t merely theological; it’s deeply intertwined with issues of justice, equity, and societal well-being. As Muslims, it’s crucial to navigate these waters with knowledge and understanding. To truly grasp the intricacies of Islamic teachings on finance and other life aspects, continuous learning is key.
For further reading, visit resources from Islamic Finance Council UK and Islamic Banking and Finance Institute Malaysia (IBFIM).
Interested in diving deeper into the world of Islamic teachings? Join our courses at IQRA Network and embark on a journey of enlightenment.